Officials say this case is related to the cases of Cordell Jenkins and Anthony Haynes, two other Toledo pastors who were charged with similar crimes. According to court documents, Butler allegedly met the teen at Anthony Haynes's church and paid to have sex with a minor several times. The victim told the FBI she would have sex with Butler inside his car and that once it happened in an ally off the Anthony Wayne Trail.According to court documents Butler paid the teen for sex on most occasions. The teenage victim told the FBI she used the money to buy food for her siblings.
Victim thought she was pregnant with the Pastor's child
Court documents also say the victim told the FBI she had to take the Plan B pill after being concerned that she was pregnant with Butler's child.