Antwon Rose's Life Matters

I teach 7th and 8th grade language arts in a district located minutes away from where the 17-year-old was killed

Antwon Rose could have been my student.

I teach 7th and 8th grade language arts in a district located minutes away from where the 17-year-old was shot and killed by police.

East Pittsburgh, the neighborhood where his car was stopped and where he ran from officers before being shot three times in the back, is minutes from my house.

He went to Woodland Hills School District, minutes from my house.

Michael Rosfeld, the officer who just started working at East Pittsburgh less than two hours before he shot and killed Antwon, had been fired with cause from his previous job as a security officer at the University of Pittsburgh, where I got both my graduate and undergraduate degrees and where my wife works.

The poem Antwon wrote about not wanting to become another statistic that was read aloud at a protest was the product of an assignment I give my own classes.

So I say again – he could have been my student.

I have had many children like him.

Most of my kids are like him.

Promising, smart, burdened by fears no teenager should have to face.

When I look at the smiling picture of Antwon released to the media, he looks like so many others I have known and loved.

How many kids have sat in those seats trying to concentrate on my work while anxious about the reality of the streets they have to walk just to get home?

How many kids have been afraid that if the worst happens, the rest of us will forget their humanity?

I am a white teacher. I don’t know what it’s like to live as a black person in America except by extension of what my kids and others tell me.

When my daughter goes to school or plays in the yard, I don’t have to worry the police will consider her a threat simply because of the amount of melanin in her skin.

If he hadn’t been in that car, he’d still be alive. If he hadn’t run from police, they wouldn’t have shot.

Maybe. Maybe not.

But being in the wrong place at the wrong time shouldn’t bring with it a death sentence. Running away shouldn’t bring with it the finality of the grave.

But plenty of questions remain.

Rosfeld is still on unpaid leave. Why hasn’t he been arrested?

Civil rights writer Shaun King reports that when Rosfeld worked at the University of Pittsburgh, he had a history of harassing black students and was only let go after he harassed one of the chancellor’s own children. If true, was that reported to East Pittsburgh before they hired him?

Why is it police can apprehend white shooters with no violence, but when a suspect is black the rules of engagement start and end with bloodshed?

And I’m glad.

We need answers to those and more questions. We need justice for Antwon.

But more than anything we need to recognize that he was a human being.

He was a little boy with his whole life ahead of him.

His life matters.

I don’t say “mattered” because even though he’s gone, his life still matters.

We can’t bring him back, but we can honor who he was.

We can recognize his common humanity is the same as anyone else’s.

And we must – we MUST – make sure that things like this don’t happen again.

At absolute minimum, the hand holding it shouldn’t belong to someone tasked with the job to serve and protect.

Like this post? I’ve written a book, “Gadfly on the Wall: A Public School Teacher Speaks Out on Racism and Reform,” now available from Garn Press. Ten percent of the proceeds go to the Badass Teachers Association. Check it out.


No. 1-4

There's actually no argument about white people population being far greater my contention was just that killings made by police happen for all and we shouldn't all point our fingers as to counting which more deaths happen but why does it even have to happen. What have authorities, and congress done to solve this police mentality that killing is the best option.

Steven Singer
Steven Singer


Yes, more white people are killed by police in the US than black people. But there are way more white people in this country. Per capita, black people are killed by police at a higher rate than white people - especially unarmed black people. I think it comes out to 3.5 times more frequently. It's an intersectional problem. US police shouldn't be so trigger happy, period. But they especially shouldn't target black people so much more frequently.


Steven, this is a heart-wrenching story but according to statistics, there are more white people killed than blacks just in 2016. The best part about that article is that it offered tangible solutions like re-training our police to elarn de-escalation properly which hopefully becomes a reality.

Jon Saltzman
Jon Saltzman


Welcome to Poltical Storm Steven! This is a really good piece of writing and incredibly sad. I taught the same grade levels as you did though at a much more privileged school in Philadelphia, but it really hit me where I live- Thanks. I look forward to seeing more of your work in the future!