Supreme Court Appears To Lean Toward Allowing Census Citizenship Question

By Hansi Lo Wang and Nina Totenberg, NPR

Updated April 25 at 5:28 p.m. ET

The justices of the U.S. Supreme Court appear split along ideological lines on whether a citizenship question can be included on forms for the upcoming 2020 census.

Based on their questions during Tuesday's oral arguments at the high court, the justices appear ready to vote 5-4 to allow the Trump administration to add the hotly contested questions to forms for next year's national head count.

The liberal justices, led by Justice Sonia Sotomayor, almost immediately began peppering the Trump administration's attorney, U.S. Solicitor General Noel Francisco, with questions after the arguments were underway, criticizing the administration's justification for the question.

"There's no doubt that people will respond less" to the census if it includes the question, Sotomayor said.

Justice Elena Kagan noted that the record of evidence for the case shows the need for a citizenship question is a "contrived one."

The conservative side of the bench, however, pointed to the discretion of Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross, who oversees the Census Bureau.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh and Justice Neil Gorsuch nodded to the history of the U.S. census, asking questions about citizenship status in the past.

Read the full story on the NPR website.

Comments (1)
No. 1-1
The Happy Hamster
The Happy Hamster

Let's see what happens.



Jon Saltzman
EditorJon Saltzman
New Comment
6
Laura Dion-Jones
EditorLaura Dion-Jones
New Comment
9
TrutherTalk
EditorTrutherTalk
New Comment
14
Poli Storm
EditorPoli Storm
New Comment
10
TrutherTalk
EditorTrutherTalk
New Comment
10
TrutherTalk
EditorTrutherTalk
New Comment
12
Poli Storm
EditorPoli Storm
New Comment
11
Poli Storm
EditorPoli Storm
New Comment
10
TrutherTalk
EditorTrutherTalk
New Comment
12
Poli Storm
EditorPoli Storm
New Comment
5